The Outlook for Someday Someday Workshops Someday Leaders Someday Challenge Someday Stories Film-making Toolkit About the Project Facebook Vimeo YouTube Sign up for our newsletters

2020 Someday Challenge Judging Team

Julie Cadzow - Vista Foundation

Eden Vawdrey - Someday Storyteller

Bala Murali Shingade - Someday Storyteller

Lanita Ririnui - Someday Ambassador

Adrienne de Melo - Department of Conservation

Amber Pierce - Auckland Council


Judging Questions

Here are the questions our Judging Team ask themselves to decide which films are Winning Films.

  1. Is the film relevant to the theme of sustainability and does it show us your 'outlook for someday'?

  2. Are the idea(s) and/or message(s) clear?

  3. How well does the visual and audio approach support the idea(s) and/or message(s)?

  4. How well does the visual and audio quality support the content of the film?

  5. Is the film original / creative / distinctive / powerful / challenging / inspiring / funny?

  6. Does the film just grab the judges and demand to be chosen for a reason they can't explain?

That last question is our 'wildcard' question. Sometimes a film is a great film precisely because it doesn't fit with existing ideas, guidelines or formulas. It just stands out. We think the starting point for a film like that is when you decide to make a film about something you really care about.

And finally, if you want to win, remember that quality and content are both important. If your film has great ideas but we can’t see it or hear it properly, then those great ideas are wasted on the Judges. And if it’s a technical masterpiece but a boring imitation of something else, then all those techniques are wasted too.